Part 2 of 5 — The 2027 Leadership Reset: a Republican Forum series on the RNC and the California GOP
First, Let the 50 State GOP Parties Choose Their Own Leaders
Republican Forum | Opinion & Analysis
Part 1 argued that the RNC chairmanship should be an examination of leadership, not a coronation. This installment asks a question about timing: before the Republican National Committee selects its next national chairman, should every state Republican Party have the chance to elect and seat its own leadership?
Why should the RNC elect its next national chairman before the state parties have finished choosing their own leaders?
State party chairs serve different terms, operate under different bylaws and face different election schedules. Some states have leadership contests coming up, some have just elected a chair, and others may have vacancies or internal disputes. Yet the national election arrives in January 2027. That raises real questions about timing, representation and the relationship between the national committee and the states.
1. The states should have a meaningful voice in the national debate
The Republican Party is not simply an organization headquartered in Washington, DC. It is a network of state and territorial parties, county committees, local clubs, elected officials, volunteers and voters. State parties do much of the work that national leadership depends on: they organize locally, recruit candidates, develop volunteers, build relationships with voters and coordinate election efforts.
Their leadership matters. A newly elected state chair should be able to take part in the national discussion as the representative of the organization he or she was chosen to lead.
2. A proposal: finish the state process before the national election
One proposal deserving serious consideration is a sequence in which state party leadership elections are completed, newly elected chairs are formally seated, and only then does the national committee hold its leadership election. Under this approach, the RNC would first establish the status of each state party’s leadership, identify vacancies and resolve questions about representation.
This would not force any state to replace its chair. Some chairs would be reelected, some would step aside, and some states would choose new leaders. The point is that each state should complete its own process under its own rules before the national vote.
3. Why new state leadership could change the conversation
A new generation of state chairs could bring different priorities and different expectations of the national committee. Some may emphasize stronger county organizations. Others may focus on fundraising, candidate recruitment, voter outreach, election operations or financial transparency. Some may want a more direct relationship with the RNC and a bigger role in decisions that affect their parties.
New leadership should not be assumed to mean better leadership. Returning chairs and newly elected chairs alike should be judged by their records, their proposals and their accountability to their own state organizations.
4. This is bigger than Gruters versus Crosbie
The national conversation has revolved around two people. But the question is whether the national committee’s process adequately reflects the interests of the state organizations it serves. Gruters, Crosbie and any other candidate should explain how they would work with state parties, respect their autonomy and support county and grassroots organizations. The national chairman should not be seen as the owner of the party’s state organizations.
5. The practical questions must be answered
The RNC’s voting membership and leadership election are governed by the RNC’s own rules, while state chair elections are governed by each state party’s constitution and bylaws. A proposal to delay the national election until state processes are complete would have to be tested against the RNC’s governing rules. It would also need answers to several questions:
- Which states have chair elections scheduled before January 2027?
- Which states have chairs whose terms run past that date?
- Which states have vacancies or unresolved leadership disputes?
- How would newly elected state chairs be formally recognized?
- What authority would be required to change the timing of the RNC election?
- How would a delay affect the committee’s operations and election responsibilities?
These are not minor administrative details. They determine whether the proposal could be implemented at all, and what would have to change for it to work.
6. The national party should not overlook its state organizations
A national party cannot function without strong state parties. State chairs should have real opportunities to explain what their organizations need, how national resources are being used and what they believe must change. The leadership election is a natural moment to examine that relationship, including whether the RNC should be more transparent about its communications with state parties, its allocation of resources and the ways state organizations can raise concerns.
The question for January 2027
Should the RNC hold its January election on the existing schedule, or should it let the states finish choosing and seating their leaders first? There are procedural, practical and representational considerations on both sides, and the RNC’s rules and the state bylaws will matter. But the Republican Party is bigger than its national headquarters, and any discussion of national leadership should take the 50 state parties seriously.
California is the largest of those state parties, and its own leadership election is coming in 2027. Part 3 turns to the state of the California GOP.
Next: Part 3: Is the California GOP Becoming a Third Party? →
The 2027 Leadership Reset: All Five Parts
- Part 1: The RNC Doesn’t Need Another Insider
- Part 2: Who Elects the Next RNC Chair? (you are here)
- Part 3: Is the California GOP Becoming a Third Party?
- Part 4: Our Leadership Crisis: Who Has a Seat at the Table?
- Part 5: Time for Rankin, Steel and Conway to Go in 2027
Looking for the county-level story? Read The San Diego GOP Accountability Series, which starts with Part 1: The Missing Candidate Hub.