Part 1 of 5 — The 2027 Leadership Reset: a Republican Forum series on the RNC and the California GOP
It Needs a Complete Leadership Reset
Republican Forum | Opinion & Analysis
The Republican National Committee’s January 2027 chairmanship election should be about accountability, transparency and reform, not about which insider gets the next promotion.
RNC Chairman Joe Gruters has President Trump’s public endorsement for another term. RNC Co-Chair KC Crosbie, whom Trump also backed for her current post, has announced that she will challenge him at the committee’s January meeting. The headlines frame this as a dramatic fight over the party’s future. The more important question is one that gets far too little attention:
Why should Republicans accept another chairman from the same leadership structure without first demanding an accounting of its performance?
The 2026 midterms left Republicans without control of Congress. After a result like that, a change of name on the chairman’s door is not an answer. At Republican Forum, we believe the RNC needs a hard look at how it operates, who makes its decisions, how it spends its money and whether its leaders answer to the Republican voters and committee members they serve.
1. No one on the current leadership team deserves an automatic promotion
The next chairman should not be chosen simply because he or she already holds a senior title. Gruters should explain the committee’s record under his chairmanship. Crosbie should explain her own record as co-chair and her earlier service as RNC treasurer. The same standard applies to every other officer.
Republicans deserve answers about election strategy, candidate support, fundraising priorities, state-party relationships, voter outreach and internal decision-making. They deserve to know what worked, what failed and who was responsible.
A presidential endorsement is a major political development. It is not a substitute for accountability. And a challenger should not be exempt from scrutiny simply because she promises change.
The January vote should not be a coronation. It should be an examination.
2. The succession question, and what we do not know
There is another part of this story that deserves attention. Our editorial opinion is that the public contest between Gruters and Crosbie leaves open a fair question: could Crosbie, a Trump-aligned Republican, ultimately prove an acceptable succession choice within the president’s political orbit?
We offer that as a question, not a finding. We have no evidence of a private arrangement, and early reporting cuts the other way: Axios reported that the White House was blindsided and angered by Crosbie’s announcement. What the public record actually shows is Trump endorsing Gruters and Crosbie, a former treasurer and current co-chair, announcing her challenge.
The press should look past personalities and headlines to the actual proposals, relationships, records and decisions behind the succession debate. And we have a warning for both sides of the contest: even if Crosbie becomes the next chair, that alone is not reform. She must say what she would change, how she would change it and how her record informs her plan. Replacing one insider with another is not the same as changing the institution.
3. The party needs reformers beyond the RNC establishment
Why is the discussion so narrowly focused on people who already hold positions inside the national committee? Republicans should be willing to hear a much wider range of voices.
Figures such as Thomas Massie, Marjorie Taylor Greene and Joe Kent have each been part of public debates about party priorities and the direction of the conservative movement. Their records and positions differ, and none should be assumed to be a declared candidate for RNC chairman. But their presence in the broader conversation raises a fair question: why should the party’s future be discussed only among those who already control its national organization?
The party should also hear from state-party leaders, county chairs, grassroots activists and people who have built political organizations outside Washington. The next generation of leadership should be determined by experience, proposals and accountability to Republican voters, not by proximity to the national establishment.
4. What real RNC reform should look like
Anyone seeking the chairmanship should be ready to answer these questions publicly:
- Financial transparency: How is the RNC spending its money, and what measurable results is that spending producing?
- State and county support: Are local Republican organizations getting the resources, training and help they need?
- Candidate development: What is the committee doing to recruit and prepare competitive candidates?
- Grassroots participation: Do the RNC’s 168 voting members have real influence over major decisions?
- Election strategy: How will the party evaluate its performance and respond when its strategies fail?
- Leadership recruitment: Is the committee developing talent beyond its existing circle of national insiders?
- Representation: Do people from every community in the Republican coalition have a meaningful path into party leadership?
These are not unreasonable demands. They are basic questions about the responsibilities of a national political organization. We take up the representation question in detail in Part 4.
5. January 2027 must be an open contest, not an establishment coronation
The RNC’s 168 voting members carry an important responsibility when the committee meets. They should not treat the vote as routine. They should demand answers from current leadership, weigh competing reform proposals and consider candidates from outside the existing leadership circle. Gruters should explain why he deserves another term. Crosbie should explain why her leadership would produce change. Any additional candidate should meet the same standard.
No one should be handed the chairmanship because of a personal relationship, an endorsement, an existing title or a promise to do better. The decision should rest on transparent discussion and clearly stated plans. Next in this series, Part 2 asks a question about the vote itself: should the states get to finish choosing their own leaders first?
6. The party belongs to its voters, not its management
The RNC serves the Republican Party. It does not own the party, its voters or the conservative movement. Its officers are temporary stewards who answer to the organization and the people it represents.
Crosbie may become the next chair. Gruters may keep the job. Another candidate may enter the race. None of that should stop Republicans from asking whether the existing structure is delivering what the party needs. The issue is bigger than Gruters, bigger than Crosbie and bigger than the White House: it is whether the party is willing to open its doors to new leadership, examine its failures, give grassroots members a real voice and hold its national organization accountable.
No automatic promotions. No unquestioned insiders. No blank checks. The 2027 RNC election should begin a serious conversation about the future of the institution, not simply decide who gets to run it next.
Sources
Reporting on Crosbie’s challenge and Trump’s endorsement of Gruters: Axios and Just the News. Current RNC officers are listed on the RNC leadership page.
Next: Part 2: Who Elects the Next RNC Chair? →
The 2027 Leadership Reset: All Five Parts
- Part 1: The RNC Doesn’t Need Another Insider (you are here)
- Part 2: Who Elects the Next RNC Chair?
- Part 3: Is the California GOP Becoming a Third Party?
- Part 4: Our Leadership Crisis: Who Has a Seat at the Table?
- Part 5: Time for Rankin, Steel and Conway to Go in 2027
Looking for the county-level story? Read The San Diego GOP Accountability Series, which starts with Part 1: The Missing Candidate Hub.
Leave a Reply